When Jonathan Wiley writes: > I have to decide in what sense it is right > to consider myself an individual > and in what sense it is right > to consider myself a member. I infer him to be more of an individualist than he asserts. The deliberate choice even of a communal as opposed to a particular religiosity seems to me an ineluctably individual act. I think we both recognize the pervasive dialectic between individual and community, and within this dialectic, each of us finds a position that corresponds to his/her needs. Historically the contradiction is dramatized in the contrast between the hermit and the monk. The corresponding dialectic in Kierkegaard's experience seems to me to be reflected in his conflict with Martensen and his attack on the Danish state church in the last year of his life. The institution which Kierkegaard attacked so vehemently from a highly individualistic perspective, obviously had deep meaning for him.