Dear Marion, Thank you very, very much for your thoughtful letter about Chapter 7. I will think about it and reply in detail probably tomorrow - i.e. later today. My very preliminary thoughts are: 1) I too am dissatisfied with Albert's sermon. 2) Stylistically it's not necessary that Albert's speech be canonically valid. All that is required that it set forth a consistent point of view, even if that view is (ultimately) indefensible. 3) The faultiness of Albert's reasoning becomes clear when he is killed by one of the bears whom he has fed and befriended. 4) The name Albert, I borrowed from Albert Schweitzer who, as you probably know was also a musician - he had a piano in his apartment in Equatorial Africa, and who espoused a philosophy which he referred to as reverence for life (Ehrfurcht vor dem Leben). Albert's sermon is an exploration of the implications of that notion, the ultimate in animal liberation. 5) It was not Caiphas and Pilate who sacrificed Jesus. Jesus sacrificed himself imitating the prescription of Isaiah 53. Again, I'm not proselytizing, when I point out that the crux of that religious revolution was the substitution with inwardness (individuality) with logos, with the word (of God) of the outwardness (public nature) of the Mosaic legal corpus. Note the contrast of language as a focus of individual meditation with language as public prescription. (I propose to translate theology into theory of literature.) As I pointed out early on - and it made you laugh, - the "I am that I am" at the burning bush, and the prohibition against naming deity constitute an analogous, parallel transformation of religious experience. The name is by its nature public and objective; the prohibition against uttering the name makes that which had previously been objective, public and outward into something subjective, private and inward. That is why I consider Christianity, - which unavoidably becomes public and objective, - to be forever in need of recursion to its Mosaic roots. - I hear you laughing. ================= I'm quite calm, not agitated at all. It's all literature. I get carried away by the drama and the rhetoric. Jochen