Peter, Klemens' letter to Alex which I copy below without being authorized do so, will provide you with a valuable perspective: ============================================================= Dear Alex, I was extremely angry at you over the weekend. Now, I am just exhausted and indifferent. I considered it my prerogative and my responsibility to schedule and organize a memorial service for my mother. I do not need a memorial service, I did not want a memorial service, but I understood that other members of the family did, and I wanted to fulfill my obligation to them. If there were to be a memorial service, I imagined, perhaps incorrectly, that it would be important to the people who needed the service that I attend. If I were to attend, it was important to me that I should determine its form, and to the greatest extent possible, its content. I was unable, because I was emotionally undermined by my children, to produce the memorial service on the somewhat rushed schedule dictated by Janet and Rebekah, and proposed holding a service sometime in spring or early summer. You told my father that this was not satisfactory. You took it upon yourself, without consulting me, to make other arrangements. I was profoundly hurt. You may have interrupted your efforts in deference to my fury, but I understand Peter Bingham, as Janet's proxy, to be doing the same thing in his correspondence with my father. I refuse to read it. Benjamin and Laura tell me that I do not own the memorial service, that it is "about Margaret, not about you." That is nonsense. My mother is DEAD. A funeral is for the survivors. I understand now that I should have paid more attention to Janet's need to get the event out of the way, to accomplish this task, to be shrinky, so that she can die. Perhaps you feel the same way. I am sorry that I am selfish, but I am. I consider what has happened to be an expropriation of my experience which is not susceptible to restitution. Burying one's dead, I hardly need instruct you, is the most personal matter. (When Ben Spock died, his second wife danced on the roof of his hearse as the cortège drew through San Diego; I can only imagine his childrens' feelings. Baby and Child Care, folks.) I cannot now attend any memorial for my mother, even if I were to organize it. On Sunday, I made arrangements to be on call for the three day weekend including January 17, so that there should be no question about whether I were physically able to attend the memorial service. If the service is rescheduled to another time, I will also be on call, or out of town. My mother was amused when a Catholic patient described attending Mass on Saturday afternoon rather than on Sunday morning as "getting it out of the way." I suggest that you get my mother's memorial service of the way on January 17. You are now probably angry at me, but I am, I reiterate, just exhausted. I plan to dissolve myself in the details of my work. I feel the genuine affection and regret in your two emails, and I apologize deeply for being so angry; I literally, in several senses, cannot help myself. I remain very fond of you. However, I do not wish to discuss this matter further. Please leave me out of it. Klemens ===============================================================, I will not attend a Memorial Service without Klemens. In the context of the foregoing letter, I see no possibility in the near future of a "Memorial Service" which Klemens and I would attend. Jochen